Researchers at Microsoft have found that the average human attention span is a depressingly low 8 seconds. In comparison, the attention span of a goldfish is even a surprising 9 seconds and almost two decades ago, our attention span was actually four seconds longer. Many researchers have attributed this decline to the growing digital age that has bombarded us with continuous streams of content, meaning we had to learn how to quickly filter and find information that’s actually relevant to us. However, it is unfortunate we enacted this process upon the what-used-to-be beautiful world of YouTube cooking.
Every kid had some phase where they got into food and cooking. When I was a little kid with nothing better to do, I would pull up 20-minute long YouTube videos teaching me how to make stew or steak and watch in astonishment as they finely cut vegetables and elegantly seared different meats. But my favorites were always the baking channels such as Nerdy Nummies by Rosanna Pansino, How To Cook That by Ann Reardon, and How To Cake It with Yolanda Gampp where they posted 20-40 minute videos of just elaborate cake making/decorating. I even made several entertaining attempts at baking and cooking along with these amazing chefs but it somehow never ended as great as the final result of their videos.
So you can probably envision how depressed I was when I went back to the How To Cook That channel after a few years where she started asking viewers to support her on the fundraising site Patreon, something she’s never asked from her viewers. When I watched her channel as a kid, it was booming. She was celebrating million after millions of subscribers but now struggles to get decent and sustainable views on her cooking videos.
What happened to this amazing and high-quality corner of YouTube? I blame this tragedy on our shortening attention spans. All the past viewers of these authentic cooking channels have moved to other channels that now focus more on speed and pumping out content than actual viewer engagement. For example, you may be among the 17.4 million subscribers of Buzzfeed Tasty, a subchannel of Buzzfeed on YouTube that often posts extremely short cooking videos lasting only 1-2 minutes long. They promise
their viewers that they upload new recipes every day yet much of their content is often variations on old videos and their cooking compilations are simply the same 10 recipes used over and over again. But you can imagine that for a teen who can barely conjure the motivation to do their homework, this kind of content is exactly what they need. Its quick, easy, and undisruptive. Unlike the 30-minute long baking videos other cooking channels post, these videos mean people don’t have to sacrifice productivity and relaxation. With everyone’s bustling schedules, people nowadays simply don’t have the time now to get invested in long, strenuous videos that require attention each second.
There are some channels out there who simply don’t even care about the content they post. So Yummy is another popular “cooking” channel with over 8 million subscribers that posts the same short, sped-up recipes every day to give their viewers constant, updated content. Unlike Buzzfeed Tasty, however, So Yummy recipes have actually been shown to be either complete failures or dangerous hazards. Other YouTube creators have actually tried some of So Yummy’s tutorials and have realized they simply don’t work. In a caramel decoration video, many of
the “hacks” with caramel were edited to result in the desired product when in reality, they fail and scientifically make no sense. They even suggest pouring boiling caramel over spinning electric beaters to create a caramel bird’s nest dessert decoration. However, if 12-year-old kids, their main audience, were to actually try this, they may suffer intense burns from flying caramel strings. What is disgusting is the fact So Yummy simply does not care. As long as they can somehow get videos uploaded each day, people will keep watching as this is the fast and digestible content they seem to want.
I truly hope that YouTube users can find their enjoyment for real and genuine cooking/baking videos again. These home creators work hard to provide amazing content to their subscribers and hope to share with the world their actual love for cooking. They aren’t searching for a profit and know anyone can jump into the world of cooking anytime. So when you get a few minutes to spare, make sure to check out the creators that have been a crucial pillar to YouTube’s success for so many years.
Works Cited:
McSpadden, Kevin. “Science: You Now Have a Shorter Attention Span Than a Goldfish.” Time, Time, 14 May 2015, time.com/3858309/attention-spans-goldfish/.