Justice for Justice

I thought it was love at first sight when I fell head over heels for fashion in the second grade; neon graphics and gaudy embellishments capturing my adoration through the glass of the obnoxiously loud window display. At the time, there was nothing I wanted more in this world than an awkwardly long, highlighter yellow cotton t-shirt starring a Beanie-Baby-stylized monkey donning a glittery pink polka dot dress with a matching bow. Cute, I know.

I had to beg my mom for a year to let me shop at Justice* before I ever got to step foot in that slice of pre-teen heaven. Yet after months of reading the catalogs (cover to cover and back), I knew every spread like the back of my hand. I figured I had a photographic memory, but it must be selective or something since the ability has never quite transferred over to other facets of my life. Sucks.

So, I showed up to school the next week in full popular girl uniform, which at Norton Creek Elementary School meant mid-wash jeggings and 3-D animal-themed top. We walked so furries could run. I vaguely remember getting a few compliments, maybe … possibly? And so the Justice addiction began. Unfortunately, my mom insisted we also shop at Children’s Place and GAP Kids, but I was able to gradually increase the proportion of Justice items purchased (thanks to its never-ending 40% off sale) from roughly 0.46 to 0.95. Pretty significant if you ask me. But by the time I moved, I was starting to come to my senses. Tricked out t-rexes and tiny little tares weren’t timeless, frankly they were trashy. And I was hellbent (a term I didn’t discover until a few years later, albeit) on figuring out why I ever thought otherwise. 

Turns out, what I thought was love at first sight was merely a deep infatuation and what I wanted most in this world wasn’t a popping primate top but to fit in with my peers. St. Charles is a fairly homogenous town and other than this one other girl in my grade who had a “white-washed” name, I was the only one like me. I couldn’t straighten my frizzy hair down or wax my hairy arms away so I changed the one thing I could—my style. And while the thought nauseates me, I think deep down I may have actually kind of liked the clothes at Justice. The problem was, that was never the reason why I wore them. 

I wore them because a girl in Kindergarten once told me, while playing American Girl dolls (note: I didn’t say with, as we were quite literally pretending to be the dolls ourselves), that I could only be Kaya or Addie because I was dark. And how dare I even ask to play pretty blonde Laine or spunky little Kit, I was nothing like them. Or did I just look nothing like them? Kaya and Addie are gorgeous girls with wonderful personalities—I truly have nothing against them—but personally, I always identified more with Molly. Her orthodox nature paralleled my own in so many ways and well, I was five so I just thought the fact that she wore glasses (like me!) made her pretty darn cool. But hey, apparently my classmates didn’t think so and I was assigned to only play the Native American or African American character in all of our games. In hindsight, they probably didn’t even realize I was another race entirely. Though I left those “friends” behind when I entered public school, the incident stuck with me as a reminder to try to assimilate as much as I could. Maybe then, with an even playing field, I would get a fair shot at representing myself as I saw fit. 

It’s meant to be a telling but lighthearted story, and I definitely don’t hold anything against the two girls in my Kindergarten class (yes, there was a 3:14 girl:boy ratio, and no, I still did not find myself a boyfriend). But I think it summarizes a lot of my struggles with myself, my community, and my attempts to bridge the gap between the two for much of my early childhood. So when people ask me when I started to love fashion, I usually just say the second grade and unlock a memory long forgotten by mentioning Justice. Har-dee-har, what a good ‘ole laugh. But the story goes a little deeper than that and my relationship with my style, which has changed not just literally but symbolically over the years, says everything about me in a nutshell.

———————————————————————————————————————————–

I fell back in love, or should I say, fell in love for the first time, with fashion in the fourth grade. It was then that I started to experiment, create, dare, celebrate, and truly express myself. And though I feel myself regress back into my shell at times, something as simple as putting on a defining outfit, one that I wouldn’t normally want to showcase to the world but love to wear in the comfort of my own home, helps me fortify my sense of self. 

Not to be dramatic or anything, but fashion is definitely my soulmate. Anyone that comes after will just have to settle for second. 

 

 

 

 

*According to Google “Justice is an online clothing and lifestyle retailer targeting the tween girl market, formerly owned by Tween Brands, Inc., later by Ascena Retail Group, and currently by Bluestar Alliance LLC. Justice sells apparel, underwear, sleepwear, swimwear, lifestyle, accessories, and personal care products for girls age 6–14”

4 thoughts on “Justice for Justice

  1. mcfleury

    This was a great blog, Eshani! I definitely have heard so many girls our age talk about the same things as far as loving Justice goes. I remember always wanting to have the cool pencils and journals when I was in the younger grade, mostly because my school has uniforms and we weren’t allowed to wear the clothes, so the rainbow glitter pen was the next best thing. I also remember my mom saying Justice was pretty expensive and as I look back I whole-heartedly agree, especially because kids grow out of clothes so fast. I loved how you connected this to the pressure that you felt to fit it. I think a lot of girls go through the same thing at that age. It is crazy to see how a person figures out who they are and how different it is from that elementary school self. Great blog!

    Reply
  2. pmgarlough

    I also feel so much embarrassment when looking back on my peace-signs-and-Justice-to-fit-in phase, and it was super interesting to me to read about the roots of yours. Also… this just unlocked a 4th-grade memory: do you remember Fashion Academy from our bus rides? I’ll be honest, I think I forgot every rule and piece of trivia I learned from that, but I do remember it being very entertaining watching you absolutely torment Mehek and Evan.

    Reply
  3. hgmitchinson

    Awesome blog post! I initially clicked on it to get a wave of that awkward, brightly colored pre-teen nostalgia, and I did, but you also delivered a really sweet narrative of your personal relationship with fashion. I like that you explored how initially you wanted wear Justice in order to fit in with the girls you felt othered around, but as you got older you started using fashion as a method of personal expression. As someone who also loves, fashion, I had a similar progression as this growing up and it’s really cool to hear someone else’s perspective 🙂 Keep up the good work!

    Reply
  4. askhan

    Hi Eshani! I really enjoyed this- it started off lighthearted and turned into something very meaningful. Regarding American Girl dolls, It’s intersting that you were automatically “assigned” to that doll, because I liked the Native American doll the best as her skin/hair color was the closest to mine. Either way, there was no South Asain doll at the time, but maybe there is now? Hopefully! Anyway, like you said, Justice was the epitome of elementary school fashion, despite its bright neon colors that could give anyone a headache. Even from a young age, you realized that clothing is something you can control, unlike other things like hair and race. It’s really sad that this realization came from not being able to fit in with the “popular” girls- however, I’m glad that you eventually found a true love for fashion and use it to express yourself rather than conform!! Thank you so much for sharing this 🙂

    Reply

Leave a Reply to pmgarlough Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *